Pepperoni and Sausage pizza was yummy. Crust was golden crispy on the bottom just the way we like it, sauce was tasty, plenty of cheese and toppings. Staff was friendly and atmosphere was calm, relaxing, and we had a great time. Blueberry sangria was also great

Four of us ate lunch at Olde Town today, 9/4/2024 We started with the Garlic Bread with Cheese. it was excellent! My wife and I enjoyed the Hawaiian Specialty regular crust and to our surprise our friends ordered the same only on a thin crust. We all thought the pizzas were top notch! It has been a while since we've been here and the only sad part, I missed the salad bar. Food is great, service was good, the ambiance is even better since my last visit, and it has been a few years. Would I recommend to family and others? You betcha! Visit Old Towne and enjoy some great food!

For the area, it's decent pizza, but having lived on both coasts including Chicago, I'm probably a pizza snob. Having said that, this place is still decent.

Great pizza! Love the mini deluxe pizza. That and a salad is a great meal for 2. We always do carry out and it's always hot.

On our quest for the best eat in pizza shops in Ohio, we found Old Town Pizza House in Amherst to be very very good. Our waiter was Max and he did a fantastic job of going over the menu with us and pointed out some of the more popular items. We had a salad where you get to choose your toppings which is great as this minimizes food waste. The salad was great. We ordered traditional crust large pepperoni and an italian sausage woogie bear. The pizza was cooked well done as requested and had a good crunch and chew. The pepperoni was fresh and the sauce had a hint of sweet and spicy. The sauce sat well with both of us - no heartburn.. The pizza serving pans were dimpled which is critical in keeping crust from getting soggy. The woogie bear was fantastic. Chris loved the italian sausage and felt it stole the show. The marinara dipping sauce was excellent. Max was our main contact and he was fantastic, but the hostess, and other staff wirk together as a team to make the experience and service top notch. We will be back soon to sample the thin crust and foldovers. If you havent tried it yet, go try it yourself. They have made our top 5 shops for perfect execution and great food. Chris & Trudy approved!

The pizza is absolutely amazing. The crust is soft yet crunchy, and the cheese was so gooey. The pizza also saves well for leftovers and heats up great. The service was good for a lunch rush, and the prices were average. The location is cute in downtown Amherst and the inside is so fun with how it's decorated.

Wonderful pizza. I also get the calzones and woogie bears. Their salads are also top notch.

It's been awhile since I've eaten here. Use to work in Amherst. I am pleased to say the food is as good as I remember. The pizza, calzone, and woogie dough is the best around. All the food ordered at my table was delicious. The grilled chicken salad was huge. The fettuccine was awesome. Thanks Olde Town for still being as good as I remembered.

I got the Large BLT fold over with extra bacon. I would recommend this to anyone who wants something different & don't know what to get. I love this BLT I'm addicted.

I absolutely love this restaurant. The servers are so pleasant and are willing to make your experience a good one. I see a lot of regulars when I done there. They enjoy a wide variety of dishes, with pizza being the signature dish. Darrell runs a fine establishment that really is a jewel in this community.